Sunday, April 13, 2014

Modi rally, Jamshedpur

Jamshedpur, April 10


BJP's Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi, someone who rarely interacts with the media, apologised to journalists on Thursday in Jamshedpur for the inconvenience caused to them by those attending his rally.

Modi, who had just begun his speech at the Gopal Maidan, apologised after people broke through multiple barricades to enter an enclosure meant for the media and invited "VVIPs" and had altercations with some journalists. "Help the press; do not trouble them. These are people who have to run around more than us politicians during elections," he said, after taking a 15-second pause during his introductory remarks to observe the chaos right in front of him.

After sternly asking those who were standing on chairs to sit, he addressed journalists in English: "I am sorry for that."

Nearly the first quarter of Modi's 19-minute speech to the brimming Gopal Maidan was about Jamshedpur and its labourers. "If the government's policies were in the right direction, we could have had a world-class automobile industry here," he said, adding that the villages around the city could become satellite towns. "We are a country that exports wheat and imports atta to make our rotis. We export iron ore; we import steel," he said.

He answered Congress President Sonia Gandhi's charge that the BJP is claiming that it would do magic overnight. "This country knows that, for the last 10 years, a black magician is sitting in Delhi. People lost jobs, farmers went into trouble and soldiers were beheaded," Modi charged, asking people to remove the black magician.

At one point in the speech, Modi tried to explain the contours of his government by asking the crowd, "What kind of a government do you want in Delhi?" The crowd chanted, "Modi Sarkar." Modi replied by asking, "I am not asking you whose government you want, but what kind of government you want." The crowd chanted back the same answer.

Gently, Kora steps back

Published here
Manoharpur, April 5


Madhu Kora wants the spotlight away from himself. He begins the interview, given on Saturday in West Singhbhum district's Manoharpur town, by saying with a smile and folded palms, "Better if you meet the Jai Bharat Samanta Party's candidate and interact with her. She will be here on the 10th [of April]."

Kora is of course referring to wife Geeta Kora (30), also the MLA from his former constituency Jagannathpur and a party he founded to serve them both. After ensuring his wife took over his assembly constituency while he went to Delhi, the outgoing MP of Singhbhum - on bail in all three cases and yet to be convicted - now wants her to take over his current position too, as he tackles investigations by multiple agencies into his financial assets as well as the 2006-'08 stint as chief minister.

So, is Kora retiring from politics? "No, no. No question of that. I will remain active and work for the people of the area. I will keep trying to make their lives better," he said. He is still his party's star campaigner and was in Manoharpur at eight in the morning, walking through the town, asking for votes. He later sat under a canopy outside his party's office - much more elaborate than the adjacent Congress campaign office - interacted with people in the Ho dialect, blessed children and even signed autographs.

However, there is an air of withdrawal about him: a desperation to be away from the public eye. "Yes, there were talks with the Congress to facilitate Geeta's joining the party. But that did not work out," he said. Then, after a pause: "Not me. Just Geeta." There are rumours that Congress, which has fielded its own candidate here, will extend tacit support to Geeta - but Union Minister Jairam Ramesh, who addressed a meeting in town later in the day, rejected the notion.

Kora is sure where his loyalties lie: "My thinking is more aligned with the UPA than the BJP." When pressed about his thoughts on Narendra Modi, he said, "He thinks his Gujarat model is applicable everywhere. There is a zameen-aasmaan difference between Gujarat and Jharkhand. I have been to Gujarat and have seen the pitiable condition of adivasis there."

Kora is 43; he is no longer the 35-year-old legislator who went on to become the first Independent chief minister of the country. On bail since July last year, he has visibly put on weight. Silver has made an appearance on his mustache; the hairline has receded with his credibility.

However, Kora retains the ability to smile at adversity like he always has - an almost shy smile, even when posed uncomfortable questions with supporters waiting on him: "The authorities keep pursuing me and the media encourages them. Officials of the Election Commission visited my house earlier this week; the media reported they were from the Income Tax. People allege Madhu Kora gets votes by spending money; the people will give them an answer."

As campaign begins, BJP frets over four seats

Published here
Ranchi, April 3


Owing to the selection of up to four candidates whom the party hopes will win solely by riding the "Modi wave," the Bharatiya Janata Party - which started from a position of strength in the state this general elections - is at the moment looking at a realistic target of winning the same number of seats it had won in 2009.

The irony is that these four candidates - "outsiders" in their own ways - were selected over local leaders of the party who could have won the seat in their own right. They were overlooked to either install an individual preferred by the party's Delhi-based leadership or to influence the state's politics.

The selection of candidates in Hazaribagh, Palamu, Chatra and Jamshedpur means that the party is targeting a minimum of eight out of Jharkhand's 14 seats. This is the same number it won in 2009; BJP lost the Jamshedpur seat to the JVM(P) in a 2011 by-election.

BJP leaders are hoping that the Modi wave will pull these candidates over the line at some point during the three-phase election in the state. "The BJP wants to win all the seats in the state, but the minimum has been set at eight. We are hoping that it will be more than 10 seats by the end," said Abhay Singh, Jamshedpur-based Working Committee member of the BJP. The BJP and JVM(P) are the only parties contesting in all 14 seats.

This, for a party which went for the safety-first approach by re-nominating six of the eight men who had won in 2009 along with two contestants who lost. Devidhan Besra from Rajmahal and Arjun Munda from Jamshedpur were replaced. Munda, whose resignation from the Lok Sabha to become chief minister prompted the 2011 by-poll, decided to opt out to focus on state politics. There is no effort to attract youngsters or women: the only under-50 candidate is the 35-year-old Sunil Soren, contesting from Dumka; there are no women.

The party has cut out the flab and decided to give out only one message to workers - vote for Narendra Modi. "It really is a monologue from our side to the voters, asking them to make Narendra Modi Prime Minister. There is no other specific strategy; workers have been asked to focus on Modi and to make him Prime Minister," said senior leader Saryu Rai.

Though it sounds easy on paper, this is not so smooth on the ground. Rural votes are transferred by satraps or groups often based on caste, tribe and religion. Choosing individuals who may not fall in their good books may have actually worked against the party. "My understanding is that the Modi wave in Jharkhand is essentially an urban phenomenon. This will work well for us in Jamshedpur, because our candidate has good presence in the rural areas already. It is already a neck-and-neck battle out there; a good number of voters who support [JVM(P)'s] Ajoy Kumar will come over to us after Modi visits the city ahead of the April 17 polls," opined a leader.

Bidyut Baran Mahato in Jamshedpur is one of the two JMM men who defected to the BJP ahead of the polls to get tickets. The other was Hemlal Murmu, who replaces incumbent BJP MP Devidhan Besra in Rajmahal. "Yes, there was a feeling inside the party which said, "Let's weaken the JMM" this time. Jamshedpur and Rajmahal are two places where the BJP considered itself in a winning position; there was also a chance to hit the JMM and we took it," said Rai.

Jamshedpur brought to the fore the differences between the state unit of the party. Leaders like Rai and Raghubar Das were against Arjun Munda's recruitment of Mahato, arguing instead that Munda should himself contest against Ajoy Kumar. "Munda wants to be the chief minister and by bringing in Mahato, he killed two birds with a stone. Leaders like Saryu Rai want to pack Munda to Delhi; he wants to stay here," said a Munda loyalist.

Another decision that could backfire is the ticket given to outgoing Hazaribagh MP Yashwant Sinha's venture capitalist son Jayant Sinha. "Yashwant Sinha would not have won this time from Hazaribagh anyway. He wanted to avoid the embarrassment and use the opportunity to introduce his son," said a BJP leader not in the Sinha camp.

Palamu is the third constituency where massive discontent brews among the cadre. BJP workers are angry that three-time-MP Braj Mohan Ram was overlooked in favour of former Jharkjhand DGP V.D. Ram, who is not from the state and joined the party only in 2013.

At dalit-dominated Chatra, the choice of Bihar-based Sunil Singh - a Rajput and an RSS nominee - could end up troubling the BJP as the Congress as well as the JVM(P) have fielded OBCs. The denial of ticket to outgoing Chatra MP Inder Singh Namdhari - an Independent who had won with the support of BJP - could also hurt the BJP as Namdhari is actively working against Sunil Singh as well as V.D. Ram.

However, the Modi factor may work in subtle ways in rural areas. "Narendra Modi is of the Teli caste, so we are expecting the Telis to vote for the BJP in large numbers. This could eat into the votes of other candidates, too - like the Congress' Dhiraj Prasad Sahu, a Teli, in Chatra," said Abhay Singh. Saryu Rai believes the Telis are only a slice of the pie. "There is a social euphoria. A large number of backward classes will be voting for the BJP this time. They see that someone like them can rise to become the Prime Minister of the country," said Rai.

Apart from the four difficult ones, Koderma and Ranchi worry BJP leaders: the former, because BJP state president Ravindra Rai is contesting and the latter because every party in the fray is making a good fist of it. "It is unusual for a state president, who should be concentrating on making others win, to contest," said a leader, indicating that not everyone was not happy with Rai's nomination. In Ranchi, there are five resourceful candidates eating into each others' vote bank. It is too early to make who has the edge in the capital, where caste equations are still being sliced and diced ahead of the April 17 polls.

One region where the BJP wants to make significant gains is the Santhal Pargana, where the Santhals have never trusted the party. Arjun Munda has had to take a backseat there because of his identity and Godda MP Nishikant Dubey seems to be making a bid to be the party's face in the region. "In 2009, Durga Soren [since dead, the eldest son of Shibu Soren] took tribal votes away from the Congress, handing us a narrow victory. We have to see if Dubey can repeat his victory. To his credit, he has consistently taken on the JMM, vocally attacking its leaders," pointed out Saryu Rai. At the time of withdrawing support to the Arjun Munda government last year, Hemant Soren had accused Dubey of insulting his father Shibu and demanded an apology.

Rajmahal and Dumka are the two other constituencies in the Santhal Pargana. The BJP is hoping that it will gain as its opponents cancel itself out. In Rajmahal, Hemlal Murmu is a leader in his own right. Apart from that, allies JMM and Congress are at each others' throats over Hemant's poaching of former Youth Congress Rajmahal president Vijay Hansdak, son of a former Congress MP. In Dumka, site of the fight of the heavyweights, an effervescent BJP hopes that Shibu Soren and Babulal Marandi [JVM(P)] will cancel themselves out. "Billi ke ladayi mein bandhar lejayega," quipped a BJP leader.

Sonia gets lukewarm response at Ramgarh

Ramgarh, April 4


Congress President Sonia Gandhi addressed a poorly-attended rally in Ramgarh town on Friday, and though she never addressed Narendra Modi by name, delivered a severe criticism of his Prime Ministerial ambitions.

During most of her 11-minute speech to request votes for the party's Hazaribagh candidate Saurabh Narain Singh, Sonia matter-of-factly listed the achievements during 10 years of the UPA rule. "These things were not easy to do. The Opposition placed hurdles before us each step of the way. However, nothing will stop us from helping the poor," said Sonia.

The meeting, scheduled to begin at 12 in the afternoon, began half an hour late. However, that was no relief for the organisers, who were frantically exhorting people to walk into the barricaded venue. That the rally happened around jum'ah hours didn't help matters. By the time Sonia's chopper descended, an unenthusiastic crowd - quarter the size Rahul Gandhi had drawn for his cancelled Gumla rally of April 1 - had turned up.

"Others say they will make magic overnight. Has it come to it that one has to tell the most lies to become the Prime Minister of this great country? There are people who will go to any extent to capture the chair," said Sonia.

Sonia said that the Congress does not lie to the electorate. "We have fulfilled each promise made in our 2009 manifesto. The same will happen for our 2014 one: we do not lie; we will complete each point," she said.

Earlier in her speech, Sonia also referred to violence without making it clear whether she was talking of Narendra Modi or Maoists. "Any kind of violence is a threat to our social fabric," she said. She then went on to say that those who have a history of violence should come into the mainstream.

Keeping in mind she was talking in the coal town of Ramgarh and referred to its coal workers. "Remember that it was the government of Indira Gandhi that nationalised coal mines. The Congress has always kept in mind the people who work in mines," she said.

Though short, the speech was not without its gaffes. Sonia addressed Jharkhand Finance Minister and Congressman Rajendra Prasad Singh - present onstage - as Rajendra Pratap Singh. At one point, she used the word "vanvasi," a term preferred by the RSS when it talks about the adivasis.

JVM's Chatra candidate gets Maoist support

Published here
Chatra, April 5


Babulal Marandi's JVM(P) is trying to capture Chatra by offering its voters their first-ever MP from within the constituency, but a whisper campaign is threatening to derail the effort.

Her opponents say in private that Neelam Devi, a 37-year-old housewife who was previously not known as a leader, has the support of the CPI-Maoist. A top police officer said there were indications that the CPI-Maoist's Regional Committee member Nakul Yadav is supporting Neelam. "We cannot prove it in any way, but I have come to know that this candidate's family is close to Nakul Yadav and that he has declared his support for her," said the officer, who talked on the condition of anonymity.

However, another officer, who works in the region denied any knowledge of this. "Even I came to know of this allegation through informal conversations. We have no such information about her," said a top police officer who serves in the region. For the record, her affidavit states that Neelam has no criminal cases against her.

The CPI-Maoist officially declares a vote boycott, but candidates and political parties often find themselves having to negotiate with LWE organisation for tacit support.

The allegation is interesting also because of the JVM's history with the Maoists. Babulal Marandi's son Anup was killed by alleged Maoists in October 2007; Babulal himself alleged on March 13 that his political opponents had given a supari to left wing extremists to murder him.

The JVM(P) has made several shrewd moves while deciding on the candidacy of Neelam - and it seems to be paying off at the moment, as she is constantly mentioned among the top three candidates in Chatra.

As things stand, along with Singhbhum's Geeta Kora, Neelam is one of the two women candidates in 14-constituency Jharkhand with a realistic chance of victory - none of the BJP, Congress and JMM have nominated woman candidates. Neelam is the only woman in the JVM's list. Conscious of the fact that the BJP's campaign targets men almost exclusively - only a handful of women turned up for Narendra Modi's March 27 rally in Chatra town - the JVM is going the extra mile to appeal directly to women voters.

However, what makes Neelam particularly appealing to voters is the fact that she - a resident of Latehar's Chandwa - is among the select few residents from the constituency get a winnable ticket. No resident from within the constituency has ever won the Chatra seat. "Even when we were part of Bihar and when we had Gaya along with Latehar and Chatra districts within the constituency, no one from these places won," said Mohammad Ehsan, the JVM(P)'s constituency incharge. In fact, neither the BJP nor the Congress has even given tickets to local leaders.

That trend continues this time, with the BJP nominating Bihar's Sunil Singh and the Congress, Lohardaga's Dhiraj Prasad Sahu. Neelam Devi's Yadav identity may help her in dalit-stronghold Chatra, with Sunil Singh being a Rajput and Dhiraj Prasad Sahu, a Teli. However, the BJP is counting on a win. "A large number of Telis could end up voting for us as Narendra Modi is from the caste. There are two other Yadavs in the fray, so their vote will be split," pointed out Chatra's Lamta panchayat president Amit Choubey, a BJP supporter.

Babulal Marandi's presence and Neelam's resident status in Latehar means that the adivasis there could vote for her. "Recently, there was a meeting organised by her supporters for adivasi voters of the constituency. I could see there was a lot of support for Neelam Devi there," said Surendra Lakra, from Latehar's Balumath block.The BJP is worried about the influence of friend-turned-foe and ongoing Chatra MP and Independent Inder Singh Namdhari, who is working to defeat both Chatra as well as Palamu candidates of the party as he was denied a ticket.

However, the Muslims could hold the key. "Muslims here have not decided yet. Their primary aim is the defeat of the BJP, so they could vote en masse for the candidate they think is the closest to the BJP's. The JVM(P) is trying to get them to vote for us," said Mohammad Ehsan.

April 1; Congress does not disappoint

Gumla, April 1


After making the crowd wait for over four hours on Tuesday at the Aerodrome maidan in the town's outskirts, Congress leaders announced that Rahul Gandhi would not be making an appearance due to a malfunctioning helicopter.

It was a major embarrassment for the state unit of the party, as they had managed to draw crowds to match Narendra Modi's March 27 rally at the same venue but had to do without their star campaigner.

The irony was not lost on some people. "I knew these political parties would want to celebrate April 1 in some way," said Amit Toppo (21).

Pradesh Congress Committee's spokesperson Shailesh Sinha said a helicopter malfunction had forced the cancellation. "After his rally I Godda, there was a stopover at Ranchi. The pilot noticed smoke while trying to take off, so another aircraft was called for," he said. The Special Protection Group delayed things further. "The second aircraft was single-engine and SPG was not happy with it. By the time approvals came through, it was late. He had to leave at 5 PM," said Sinha.

Rahul also lost a chance to address crowds from the same site from which Rajiv Gandhi campaigned for Congress candidate Sumati Oraon in 1984.

Rahul was scheduled to arrive at the venue at 2 PM, though the district unit of the party had announced that he would arrive at 1 PM. There was a festive atmosphere on the grounds, not least because it was the eve of Sahrul, one of the most important adivasi festivals. However, as time wore on, people started leaving to go to the market and to prepare for Sahrul.

A large number of people stayed on the periphery of the three-tier security enclosure, so it was difficult to estimate how large the assembly was. "This is bigger than Modi's rally; the enclosure was smaller for that one," said Chama Bara (22). Lohardaga, the constituency in which Gumla falls, has a significant number of voters from the Oraon tribe. The Christian converts among them generally prefer the Congress. On the other hand, caste Hindus usually stick together. "This is nothing compared to the Modi rally. It took place on a [CPI-Maoist] bandh, too," said Vikram Kumar (18).

Congress candidate Rameshwar Oraon and Geetashree Oraon, minister in the state cabinet and the legislator from Gumla's Sisai, were among the leaders who tried to keep the crowd engaged during the four-hour wait. "My vote will still go to the Congress, but I am now worried about the party's chances here," said Krishna Tana Bhagat, part of a community that has always supported the Congress.

Some, however, went away happy. "I usually make Rs. 700 after a day's work. Today, just by standing here, I've made more. I'm out of stock!" said Nagendra Gope, who sold ice cream cones at the venue.

Better off as a Maoist

Published here
Daltonganj, March 29


There once was a Maoist. He killed thieves and separated their heads. He freed his people and returned their lands. He annhilated caste by organising intercaste marriages.

Then he went into politics and was never the same again.

"Yes, he was more effective when part of the Organisation [CPI-Maoist]. Now, he is bound by all these rules; he cannot do what he wishes," chuckled Parameshwar Baitha outside a paan shop at the Pandu market in Jharkhand's Palamu district.

Parameshwar is the younger brother of Palamu's outgoing MP Kameshwar Baitha (59). Kameshwar, who won in 2009 on a JMM ticket, is instantly recognised as the member of the 15th Lok Sabha with most criminal cases to his name. In his latest affidavit, filed as a TMC candidate, Kameshwar has said that the number of cases against him stands at 51, from 2009's 46.

Even his allies by blood agree that Kameshwar, a former CPI-Maoist Central Committee member, faces an uphill battle to retain his seat. "When we go campaigning, people are asking what he has done in the last five years. I tell them that he was in jail till 2011. Since then, he has been fighting his cases," said Parameshwar. Kameshwar was ditched by the JMM, which passed on the SC-reserved seat to the RJD in the seat-sharing agreement. He tried going over to the BJP, which favoured former DGP V.D. Ram - during whose tenures Kameshwar was in jail. Then, the TMC came calling.

"It does not matter which party he contests from. People only see Kameshwar Baitha," said Parameshwar. TMC is Kameshwar's - who tells anyone who would listen that he is the most popular dalit leader of Jharkhand - third political party: he had unsuccessfully contested the 2007 Lok Sabha bypoll on a BSP ticket.

xxxx

At Dhachabar village in Pandu block's Dalakala panchayat, Ashok Baitha sat on haunches and rubbed his palm on the dirt road. "Is this the road that should lead to the house of an MP?," he asked. Ashok is a cousin of Kameshwar and still lives in the ancestral village. The MP does not live here anymore; he owns multiple houses but is mostly in his residence in Bishrampur block.

In 2009, the village had spread out to all over the constituency to campaign for its most famous son, who was in jail. Kameshwar's wife Devmani Devi campaigned, and later, became a leader on his behalf along with their three sons. By the time Kameshwar - arrested from Bihar on May 30, 2005 - was released on bail on May 8, 2011, two years of his tenure had passed. On May 11, his former comrades bombed his house in Dhachabar.

This time, the enthusiasm is missing in the village. "No one else could give us dalits what he gave us as a rebel. We were never allowed to let our lungis lie below the knee. The zamindars never let us sit on chairs; in fact, we always had to stand," said Devlal Baitha, husband of panchayat mukhiya Anju Devi. Ashok completed what Devlal left unsaid: "He silenced the zamindars. He held marriages - even encouraged intercaste couples to get married. However, when he became a leader, he helped himself."

There is an argument in saying politics has domesticated Kameshwar. "Once, he caught four thieves. This was in Basdiha. He ordered that they be killed, then separated their heads. When the police found the thieves, their heads were neatly kept together while the rest of their bodies were piled beside," said Ashok.

This story was independently narrated by a senior police officer, who also told the tale of how Kameshwar went over to the dark side - something no one in the village claims to know about. "There was an uppercaste individual who tried to molest one of Kameshwar's sisters. The man's goons assaulted Kameshwar's mother while trying to get to the girl. When Kameshwar heard of this, he went and extracted his revenge," said the officer without clarifying what exactly the revenge was.

The road connecting Dhachabar to Pamdu town was built on Kameshwar's orders - but during those 26 years he spent as a rebel. "We had been involved in a losing litigation with the zamindar about six acres of our land. Kameshwar may have been active in Bihar; but his influence and the Organisation's goodwill meant that the zamindar was forced to return it. I know about two other cases where a total of 24 acres was returned to dalits," said Bindu Ram, who is not rooting for Kameshwar this time.

xxxx

In the neighbourhood of Dhachabar where Baitha's kin lives, they believe their hero deserves one more chance. "He came overground after so many years of living in the jungle. Two of these five years, he was in jail. Look at me, even I have not been able to bring about development despite living in my own village. Give him one more chance," said "mukhiyapati" Devlal.

Even youngsters who never saw Kameshwar the rebel think he has done a good job. "Baithaji asked 277 questions in the Lok Sabha. No other Palamu MP has done so much for the constituency," said Sunil Baitha.

"Wait and see. The TMC will form the government in Delhi and Baithaji will become a cabinet minister. He is the messiah of the poor," said a youngster. When asked for his name, he withdrew without a word. It turns out, the man is a relative of the MP as well as a police constable who is Kameshwar's bodyguard.